Phase 2 windows into a Phase 1

[puglove]

There is a difference in window regulators I know trhat but i was thinking I could swap over the entire ting, window, runner, motor etc.
I was hopeing that someone else had done it to save me the AAARGH moment after stripping out both of them only then finding out it won't go.

It can all be swaped over. I put a ph1 3door s16 reg/runner ect in the mrs ph2 xsi. no problems