Help me decide on a new car!!

[1616six]

But the OP put up those two cars as options...so he is comparing them...so Im giving an opinion based on that comparison.

Compared to thr S2000 its just too floppy, too soft, too much chassis flex. Ive seen a lot of older mx5s with glass stress damage on the windscreen due to the whole chassis flopping round for years.

When an S2000 gets to the age of an MX5 you're comparing it to, it'll have glass stress damage too. It's a small car without a roof.. do you understand the structure/strain? You're comparing two cars that will have probably 10yrs+ age difference.